RubricMark · Sample questions

University essay — critical response (first year)

University of Melbourne · Academic Writing · Public sample rubric — first-year university essay (100-level)

Free public rubric for University essay — critical response (first year) — use in RubricMark Setup or copy the criteria table into your course.

Sample prompt

Critically discuss one benefit and one limitation of students using AI writing tools when completing university coursework. Draw on at least one credible source, use in-text citations, and include a reference list. Length: 800–1,000 words.

800–1,000 words. APA 7th or discipline style as specified in your subject guide.

Rubric criteria

First-year university essay — four criteria (25 marks each)
CriterionMaxDescriptors
Argument & critical thinking25Responds to the question; nuanced discussion of benefit and limitation; analysis not only description.
Structure & organisation25Introduction with thesis; logical paragraphs; effective conclusion; headings only if appropriate.
Evidence & referencing25At least one credible source integrated; in-text citations and reference list; paraphrase over patchwriting.
Academic language & expression25Formal register; clear sentences; grammar and punctuation do not obscure meaning.